14) Allah and science part 1 (Basic mathematics)

As we know human has made enormous progress in science, For instance 4500 years ago Egyptian scientist has discovered pyramid's Volume (V=1/3. h. a.a) v=Volume, h=height and a.a=area.

Does Allah who introduce himself to Muhammad as god had knowledge how to calculate the sum of
fractional numbers? We will refer to Quran in order to find the answer.

• Sureh 4 (Al-Nesa), Verse 11, since this verse is too long I have divided in smaller sentences.

1. Male inheritor will inherit twice as much as female inheritor
   
2. If all inheritors and are female then they all will inherit 2/3
   
3. If inheritor is only one female then she will inherit 1/2
4. But the father and mother each will inherit 1/6
5. If decease has no children then mother inherits 1/3, father 2/3. But if he has brother then mother will inherit 1/6 and father 5/6
6. At the end of verse stated Allah is knowledgeable

• Continues in Verse 12:

1. You (referring to the men) will inherit 1/2 of your wife belonging if they have no child
2. If decease female had children then her spouse will inherit 1/4
3. Women will inherit 1/4 from their husband if they did not have children
4. If they had children then the wife will inherit 1/8
5. The rest of verse is explaining the rule for "kalaleh" which is explained in belog #13.

Here are 4 different situation when a man decease:

• Man=decease, Wife=inherit 1/4, Child=No, Mother=inherit 1/3, Father=inherit 2/3

The sum of (2/3+1/3+1/4=16/24+8/24+6/24=30/24), Here the sum must be 24/24 but 30/24 this means incorrect dividends.

• Man=decease, Wife=inherit 1/4, Child=No, but had brother so Mother=inherit 1/6, Father=inherit 5/6

The sum of (1/4+1/6+5/6=6/24+4/24/+20/24=30/24), Here the sum must be 24/24 but 30/24 this means incorrect dividends.

• Man=decease, Wife=inherit 1/8, Child=Yes, Daughter=1 and inherit 1/2, Mother=inherit 1/6, Father=inherit 1/6

The sum of (1/8+1/2+1/6+1/6=3/24+12/24+4/24+4/24=23/24), Again the sum must be 24/24 but it is 23/24 which is less and incorrect.

• Man=decease, Wife=inherit 1/8, Child=Yes, Daughter=more than 2 and they inherit 2/3, Mother=inherit 1/6, Father=inherit 1/6

The sum of (1/8+2/3+1/6+1/6=3/24+16/24+4/24+4/24=27/24), another math error

Here are 4 different situation when a woman decease:

• Woman=decease, husband=1/2, Child=No, Mother=inherit 1/3, Father=inherit 2/3

The sum of (1/2+1/3+2/3=12/24+8/24+16/24=36/24), So go figure how you divide.

• Woman=decease, husband=1/2, Child=No, but had brother so Mother=inherit 1/6, Father=inherit 5/6
  

The sum of (1/2+1/6+5/6=12/24+4/24/+20/24=36/24), Here the sum must be 24/24 but 36/24 this means incorrect dividends.

• Woman=decease, husband=inherit 1/4, Child=Yes, Daughter=1 and inherit 1/2, Mother=inherit 1/6, Father=inherit 1/6

The sum of (1/4+1/2+1/6+1/6=6/24+12/24+4/24+4/24=26/24), Again the sum must be 24/24 but it is 26/24 which is more and incorrect.

• Woman=decease, husband=inherit 1/4, Child=Yes, Daughter=more than 2 and they inherit 2/3, Mother=inherit 1/6, Father=inherit 1/6

The sum of (1/4+2/3+1/6+1/6=6/24+16/24+4/24+4/24=30/24), another math error


Conclusion: As we see Allah fails in every single calculation as shown above (sum of fractional numbers) but in the same verse Allah claims he is knowledgeable. As we know a 9-10 years old child can calculate the sum of fractional numbers with no mistake but here Allah fails compare to a 9-10 years old child.

13) Is Allah liar or forgetful part 4

Key word: Kalaleh (Arabic word) means men or women who has no children nor parents to inherit their belonging but they have sibling.

In Sureh 4 (Al-Nesa), Verse 12 and verse 176 explains the inherit rules in Islam for the "Kalaleh" (see above).

• Sureh 4 (Al-Nesa), Verse 12: If a person who is "Kalaleh" (has one brother and one sister) passed away then his/her brother or sister each will inherit 1/6Th (The sum of 1/6 +1/6= 2/6=1/3 ) of the belonging but if they have more than 2 sibling then they will inherit 1/3Th as well.
  

Please note: Allah forget to discriminate between men and women as we know in other Verses women inherit 1/2 of the men. If you do a simple math (1/6 + 1/6= 2/6) so what will happen with remaining 2/3=4/6? If more than one brother or sister they all will inherit 1/3=2/6, so the question is 2 inheritor will inherit 1/3 and more than 2 inheritor will also inherit 1/3. Solve this math puzzle please!!!!

• Sureh 4 (Al-Nesa), Verse 176: If a man die and has a sister then she will inherit 1/2 of his belonging. If a women die and has a brother then he will inherit all=3/3 of her belonging. If a person die who has 2 sisters then they both will inherit 2/3. But if deceased has 1 brother and 1 sister then they will inherit 2/3 but brother will 2 times than sister (brother inherit 4/9Th and sister 2/9Th).

Please note: the first part of the verse Allah has been reminded discriminating between men and women (sister 1/2=3/6 brother all=6/6) comparing with the verse 12 as mentioned above (brother 1/6 ans sister 1/6).
Second point: Simple math: 1/2=3/6 and all=6/6 if a inheritor is a man then he will inherit all=6/6 but if inheritor is a women then she will inherit 1/2=3/6 so where is the reaming 1/2?

in the second part of Verse if decease has brother will inherit all=6/6=9/9Th but if decease has a brother and a sister then they both will inherit 2/3=4/6=6/9 where is the reaming 1/3=2/6=3/9 compare to the first rule in the same verse. So two inheritor will inherit 2/3=4/6=6/9 which is less than 3/3=6/6=9/9.

3rd point: In first part of verse a brother will inherit all=6/6=9/9 but if he has a sister then he will inherit 4/9Th. So logically if we implement the rule that women will inherit 1/2=3/6=4.5/9 than men so the brother should inherit 2/3=4/6=6/9 and sister 1/3=2/6=3/9 but he inherit 4/9 and sister 2/9 and 1/3=3/9 is missing.

Conclusion: As you see each verse has its own problem and math mistakes but if you compare these 2 verse which are talking about the inherit rule for "Kalaleh" then you will find many inconsistency. the obvious inconsistency is in the first verse brother and sister will inherit both 1/6+1/6=2/6=1/3 together and same dividends but in the second verse they both will inherit 2/3=4/6 and not equal dividends.